24 May 2010

The MacGuffin













Many film thrillers employ the Hitchcock device of a MacGuffin. That’s to say some plot element which provides an excuse for the narrative to take place and propels the action forward. Think of ‘The Maltese Falcon’ or ‘North by Northwest’.



The important thing about a MacGuffin is that it doesn’t necessarily need to be that important – or even real. What it does is provide a context for exploring more important things like values and relationships.



Sometimes design plays the same role – it creates a safe place to challenge issues, an excuse to challenge deeply held precepts. Indeed, the most significant impact of design can be its role as a plot device to explore and realise new narratives. The best outcome is not always a building.

Read more...

18 May 2010

The General Theory













Discussions on how to plan for the future often reveal a hunger for theories and models which can provide us with all the answers. There seems to be an overwhelming need to wrap up observations, experiences, and anecdotes into neat packages of elegant thought.



John Maynard Keynes wrote ‘The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money’ in 1935, and a lifetime later it remains an important and influential work. Keynes had a profound impact on the way in which governments approach economic problems. Even those who disagree with him find that his work defines the framework for their dissent.



However, even Keynes embraced doubt. In his preface he wrote:

‘The writer of a book such as this, treading along unfamiliar paths, is extremely dependent on criticism and conversation if he is to avoid an undue proportion of mistakes. It is astonishing what foolish things one can temporarily believe . . ‘

Such doubt and conversations deserve to underpin all of our work.

Read more...

7 May 2010

Ash











When risk management fails us we tend to resort to ‘acts of God’ as a get out clause. When we are grounded by events we could not have dreamed of, we inevitably become fatalistic about consequences.



Where we choose to focus our investment in buildings is also a reflection of our perceptions of risk. Implicitly or otherwise we balance unlikely consequences against likely disruption. We also need to balance outcomes against opportunity cost – what else could we have spend this money on and would it have produced a better, safer solution for more people.



This is easier said than done in the regulatory and litigious environment in which we all have to make difficult decisions. Protecting lives from danger is not an alternative to changing lives for the better – but it sometimes seems that way.

Read more...

9 April 2010

Beautiful Minds









Professor Dame Jocelyn Bell Burnell is famous for being the research scientist who first discovered ‘Pulsars’. I discovered this whilst watching the BBC 4 series ‘Beautiful Minds’. During the programme, when asked about the ‘truth’ of science, she said: “If we assume we’ve arrived, we stop searching”. A quotation which certainly sounds like it comes from a beautiful mind.



This habit of stopping looking when we find a credible answer to a passing problem can become a real obstacle to innovation. The result is that we build up a wall of old truths which form a formidable barrier to the discovery of the next new truth.



Although it may be tempting to think that in some cases we can stop thinking, that we have indeed solved some issues for all time, the truth is that this is never the case. Forgetting this scientific fact is a recipe for repeating mistakes – the opposite of discovery.

Read more...

30 March 2010

Time and Space












Lifelong learning, flexible partnerships, collaboration as a default – all phrases I used at the recent Adult Learning in Scotland Conference. But what do these phrases really mean?



Firstly, they mean a small but fundamental shift in the focus of our attention: a redefinition of what we mean by success and effectiveness. Rather than ask how the institution benefits, we begin to ask how the individual benefits and to look at the greater good.



And, secondly, we look at time rather than just space. Or is that merely yet another one of those phrases? Yes it is – but that doesn’t mean it’s wrong. Rather than ask how we should timetable next year or revise the project management plan, we begin to ask how we can help an individual plan their lives and how we might affect the growth of a whole community.



We’re told in the run up to every election that ‘it’s all about the economy’. When it comes to the design of educational buildings we sometimes need reminded that ‘it’s all about learning’.

Read more...

5 March 2010

Plans










Two frequent comments at workshops: “We can’t tell you what we need unless we see some plans” - “We don’t believe you’ll listen to what we say because you’ve already drawn up the plans.” Spot the fatal flaw in reconciling this philosophical impasse.



George Orwell, in his novel 1984, talks about ‘doublethink’ – the ability to believe in two contradictory ideas at the same time. It may be a sophisticated trait but it’s an unhelpful one if you believe in making things better.



So, do we share drawings? Of course we do. But, the longer we empower the user by talking in their language, then the more likely it will be that we will have meaningful conversations which build trust and empathy. It’s never about the medium – aways about the message. But it helps if you’re understood. So, resist the urge to demonstrate graphic prowess, and keep listening.

Read more...

2 March 2010

Exuberance













There are words which we seem to exclude from our lexicon when we talk about architecture. They tend to be words we think of as less grown up: words which seem less sensible when compared with, for example, the thoughts of Vitruvius. For a start you don’t need to translate them from their classical origins.



Some words are unashamedly about how you feel – today. They escape from your thoughts like visceral responses to what is happening around you: rather like how we react to great spaces. 'Exuberance' is one of those words we rarely use about design.



William Blake said Exuberance is Beauty. He was a great poet and visionary. And we need to embrace exuberance, and words like it, if we are to inspire design that is poetic and visionary.

Read more...

www.statcounter.com

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP